One campaign says canvassers for its rival mishandled voters’ ballots. The other calls the claims false and defamatory. The next count comes Tuesday.
Just 41 votes separate the two candidates for the open 9th District seat on the Los Angeles City Council, and a complaint from one campaign accusing canvassers for the other of mishandling voters’ ballots is now with the Los Angeles County district attorney’s office.
Jose Ugarte leads Estuardo Mazariegos 19,434 to 19,393, according to county election results last updated Friday, Nov. 13, at 3:47 p.m. After Tuesday’s count, Ugarte’s lead was 156 votes, the Los Angeles Times reported.
The registrar estimates 15,000 ballots are still uncounted countywide and does not break that number down by district. The next results update is set for Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 4 p.m., and the county is scheduled to certify the election Nov. 27.
WHAT THE COMPLAINT ALLEGES
Mazariegos’ campaign said on Monday, Nov. 9, that it had filed a complaint with the registrar’s office. It alleged that people working for Ugarte’s campaign collected ballots without signing the envelope line that identifies who returned them, and in one case accused Ugarte campaigners of filling out a woman’s ballot without her knowing whom she was voting for, LAist reported.
“Taking people’s ballots, filling them out, and not following legal voter assistance guidelines in a district that has faced so much disenfranchisement is disgusting,” Mazariegos said in a statement.
On Friday, the campaign said in a statement reported by NBC Los Angeles that it had given the registrar a recording of a resident whose ballot appeared in photos the campaign had received. According to the campaign, the resident said canvassers took the resident’s blank ballot and the ballots of two other household members, and that the canvassers “said they would do the voting for the household.” “They did not ask the residents who they wanted to vote for or say which candidates they intended to fill in,” the campaign’s statement said.
UGARTE’S SIDE PUSHES BACK
Ugarte has said the Mazariegos campaign’s allegations “are categorically false and defamatory,” the Times reported.
One image the Mazariegos campaign circulated showed a USC student volunteering for Ugarte dropping a stack of ballots into a drop box. Ugarte’s campaign responded by pointing to an Instagram post in which the student said he was being bullied and falsely accused. “Why is he attacking me? For participating in our democracy, as is my right under California state law and for helping others participate in democracy, as is their right under California state law,” he wrote.
Registrar spokesperson Mike Sanchez said the office sent the complaint to the district attorney for review, and that the drop box photo alone did not raise alarms because state law lets voters authorize someone else to return a completed ballot, according to the Times. The district attorney’s office told the Times it was looking into the matter.
WHAT THE LAW ALLOWS
Justin Levitt, a constitutional law professor at Loyola Marymount University, told LAist’s AirTalk that no law caps how many ballots one person can turn in for others, as long as that person is not paid per ballot. He said it would be illegal for a voter to sign a ballot and hand it to someone else to fill out, and that any district attorney inquiry would likely center on that question.
“Even if there were some sort of administrative wrongdoing, as long as there’s no indication of fraud with the ballot itself, those ballots will all be counted,” Levitt said.
The seat is open because Councilmember Curren Price is termed out. Price, who is facing embezzlement and conflict of interest charges and has denied wrongdoing, has endorsed Ugarte, the Times reported. Ugarte is Price’s former deputy chief of staff. Mazariegos is a co-director of the Los Angeles chapter of the Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment, NBC Los Angeles reported. He is backed by the L.A. chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America, according to the Times.
The district covers much of South L.A., including USC and the Convention Center. Whoever wins will be the first Latino to represent it since Edward Roybal left in 1962 for a seat in Congress, according to NBC Los Angeles.





















